Estate Litigation Blog
Limitation Period on a Will Challenge: Shannon v. Hrabovsky
by Lisa Fenech, Published: November 16, 2018
How much time does a will challenger have to commence proceedings? The safest answer is: within two years of the date of death of the deceased. If a will challenger wants to commence proceedings after two years of the date of death, they will need to convince a court that the principle of discoverability applies in will challenges and that it applies to the circumstances of their case. The recent decision in Shannon v. Hrabovsky, 2018 ONSC 6593,offers guidance as to the application of the principle of discoverability in will challenges.
In Shannon, the deceased died on November 15, 2014. The daughter did not know of the existence of the deceased’s last will on the date of death of her father. She received a copy of it in January 2015. The daughter commenced a will challenge on December 23, 2016, two years after the death of her father but less than two years from the date that she received a copy of the last will. When did the two-year period pursuant to s. 4 of the Limitations Act run out? Does the principle of discoverability apply?
Shannon states that the principle of discoverability applies to will challenges. Pursuant to s. 5(2) of the Limitations Act, a person is presumed to have knowledge of all the necessary facts to commence litigation on the date of death of the deceased. The discoverability principle will apply if the will challenger can prove that on the date of death of the deceased, s/he was ignorant of the facts set out in s. 5(1)(a) of the Limitations Act, mainly that a loss had occurred; the loss was caused or contributed to by an act or omission; the identity of the person who acted or failed to act; and that litigation was appropriate to remedy the loss. When the principle of discoverability applies, the limitation period will start to run as of the date by which a reasonable person knew or ought to have known these facts.
In Shannon the court determined that the discoverability principle applied because, on the death of death of her father, the daughter lacked knowledge of the existence and contents of the last will of the deceased. Therefore, the presumption under s. 5(2) was rebutted and the limitation period started to run when the daughter received a copy of the last will.
Although it seems that in Leibel v. Leibel, 2014 ONSC 4516 and Birtzu v. McCron, 2017 ONSC 1420 courts had also decided that the principle of discoverability applies to will challenges, it remains for the Court of Appeal to provide binding authority on the topic.
Recent Posts
- Felice Kirsh, Jordan Oelbaum, and Sender Tator named to Best Lawyers 2021
- 2021 Top 10 Wills, Trusts and Estates Boutique
- Our law clerk Clare Aikins teaches Estates Law Course
- Felice Kirsh and Mitchell Rattner speak about Section 3 Counsel at OBA Conference
- Further Suspension of Limitation Periods and Statutory Deadlines
- Estate Litigation: Using Technology to Adapt
- Suspension of Limitation Periods and Statutory Deadlines Amid COVID-19 Pandemic
- The Courts and COVID-19
- Virtual Witnessing of Wills
- We are open during COVID 19 pandemic
- Felice Kirsh: Not every issue is worthy of a passing of accounts
- Felice Kirsh discusses the importance of record-keeping by estate trustees
- Sender Tator on Dependant Support cases and "Egregious Conduct"
- Improper Conduct and Dependant Support
- Felice Kirsh on why DIY wills are a recipe for disaster
- Felice Kirsh, Jordan Oelbaum, and Sender Tator named to Best Lawyers 2020
- Felice Kirsh discusses how lawyers should prepare their clients for mediation
- Felice Kirsh discusses the benefits of evaluative mediators
- Felice Kirsh on "Is my estate dispute suited for mediation?"
- Felice Kirsh discusses the benefits of mediating estate disputes
- Presentation at the MCBNA
- Top 10 Wills, Trusts and Estates Boutique
- No Two-Year Limitation Period for Passing of Accounts
- Limitation Period on a Will Challenge: Shannon v. Hrabovsky
- Make a Will Month
- Felice Kirsh discusses the perils of finding heirs
- The partners at SKOT LLP are Lexpert-ranked
- Probate and Privacy
- Buzz Aldrin Guardianship Dispute & the Importance of Planning for Incapacity
- The expensive consequences of being unreasonable in estate litigation
- Legally Valid Gifts
- Powers of Attorney - Common Myths
- Costs in Estate Litigation
- Capacity to reconcile or divorce
- What’s the “issue” with not updating your will?
- Top 5 Wills, Trusts and Estates Boutiques in Canada
- Mutual Wills v. Mirror Wills
- Costs in Will Challenge Litigation
- Estate Planning - Digital Assets
- 2016 Amendments to the Income Tax Act – Graduated Rate Estates and Qualified Disability Trusts
- Capacity to Enter into Contracts
- Court of Appeal overturns "racist will" decision
- Best Lawyers
- Costs Award Against Power of Attorney Personally
- Applications and Actions: dismissal for delay
- Schnurr Kirsh Oelbaum Tator LLP is heading east!
- Spence v. BMO Trust Company: the case of the racist father
- Top 5 Wills, Trusts and Estates Firms in Canada
- Quinn v. Carrigan: "No litigation outcome is inevitable"
- What you need to know before starting a will challenge: Leibel v. Leibel
- Do the claims of dependants have priority over the claims of other creditors?
- Estate Administration and Automatic Vesting
- Elizabeth Bozek to Chair OBA program "Complex Passing of Accounts"
- Jordan Oelbaum speaks about the discovery process at Osgoode Hall Law School
- Felice Kirsh speaks to financial advisors about best practices
- Best Lawyers for 2015
- Felice Kirsh to chair conference at Osgoode Hall Law School
- Parents have testamentary freedom
- Pro Bono Students Canada's Wills Project
- Leading practitioners
- Choose a power of attorney you trust
- Elizabeth Bozek chairs seminar on the Consent and Capacity Board
- Consider whether a passing of accounts is worth it
- Best Lawyers for 2014
- When estate litigation gets tense, lawyers must stay cool
- Bar Admissions Fall 2013
- Brian Schnurr, Felice Kirsh and Jordan Oelbaum named to Best Lawyers 2013
- OBA Estates and Trusts Dinner
- Trust Company Best Practices
- Brian Schnurr and Felice Kirsh named to Best Lawyers 2012
- Best Lawyers Awards Brian A. Schnurr 2011 Lawyer of the Year, Trust and Estates - Toronto
Tags
- "issue"
- 2017 onsc 2704
- 2018 onsc 6593
- accounts
- advocatedaily
- application for orders and directions
- armitage v. the salvation army
- as estate trustee of the estate of jadwiga koziarski v jesse sullivan
- as estate trustee of the estate of jadwiga koziarski v jesse sullivan 2017 onsc 2704
- attorney
- automatic vesting
- bad faith
- beneficiaries
- best lawyers
- best lawyers award
- boutique law firm
- bowmanville
- brian schnurr
- c. c.12
- c. s.26
- canada lawyer magazine
- canadian lawyer
- canadian lawyer magazine
- capacity
- case comment
- cheque
- children born outside of marriage
- children's law reform act
- children’s law reform act
- community engagement
- compensation
- conference
- conferences
- consent and capacity board
- contract law
- corona
- coronavirus
- corporate trustee
- costs
- court
- courts
- covid
- covid 19
- covid-19
- creditors
- creditors' relief act
- depandant
- dependant support
- dependants
- digital assets
- discoverability
- discovery
- dishonesty
- donee
- doner
- elizabeth bozek
- emergency
- emergency order
- equalization
- estate
- estate administration
- estate litigation
- estate planning
- estate trustee
- estate trustees
- estates
- estates administration act
- estates and trusts summit
- estates and trusts toronto
- estates boutique
- estates list
- executor
- executors
- felice kirsh
- fiduciary
- fiduciary duty
- financial advisors
- fraud
- gifts
- graduated rate estate
- guardianship
- heirs
- henry koziarski
- husband
- ilco
- incapable
- incapacity
- income tax act
- inheritance
- inter vivos
- intestacy
- issue
- jordan oelbaum
- law clerks
- leading lawyers
- leibel v. leibel
- lexpert
- limitation
- limitation period
- limitations act
- litigation
- make a will month
- mcbna; presentation; estates
- mediation
- mirror wills
- misappropriation
- misconduct
- mortgage
- mutual wills
- ontario bar association
- osgoode hall
- pandemic
- passing of accounts
- poa
- power of attorney
- powers of attorney
- privacy
- probate
- public policy
- qualified disability trust
- r.s.o. 1990
- rob levesque
- sandra schnurr
- sender tator
- shannon v. hrabovsky
- shnurr kirsh oelbaum tator
- shnurr kirsh oelbaum tator llp
- slra
- spouses
- substitute decisions act
- succession law reform act
- superior court
- superior court of justice of ontario
- support
- suspension
- tax
- tax planning
- testamentary capacity
- testator
- top 10
- top 5
- toronto
- trial
- trust and estates toronto
- trustee
- trusts
- trusts and estate toronto
- trusts and estates
- trusts and estates toronto
- virtual
- wall v. shaw
- wife
- will challenge
- will drafting
- will litigation
- wills
- wills and estates
- wills trusts and estates
- witnessing